So, here's my take: this is one of those rare albums where I like a few songs, but the other ones never grow on me to the point where I don't compulsively skip them. I like: Seeing Other People, Like Dylan in the Movies, and Mayfly (even if it mostly sounds like Dylan in the Movies); and I like parts of If You're Feeling Sinister.
So, in conclusion: it's ok it's in my collection, but I'm not gonna buy any more.
My sheep quotient: 33%
(only 1 of my 3 preferences overlaps AMG's three picks)